THE IDEA, SIMPLY

The rule, with an example

A defining clause is essential to identifying its noun and is not set off with commas. An object relative pronoun can often be omitted, but a subject relative pronoun cannot.

SEE IT IN CONTEXTThe book (that) I borrowed was useful. The book that won the prize was useful.
Skills to work on in this practice
  • Identify exactly which person or thing
  • Choose who, which or that
  • Recognise when the object pronoun can go

Decide whether the pronoun is subject or object

UseExampleWhy it works
SubjectThe person who called is waiting.You cannot remove who: the verb needs a subject.
ObjectThe book that I borrowed is useful.I is the subject of borrowed; that is the object.
Object omittedThe book I borrowed is useful.The object relative pronoun can be omitted in this defining clause.

Common mistake

Check: The person called me is waiting

Use: The person who called me is waiting

Keep a subject relative pronoun in a full defining clause.

How should I practise this?

Read the example and explain the choice before answering. After the exercise, write a new sentence using the same pattern. Revisit any answer you could not explain, even if you guessed correctly.

MORE PRACTICE · SAME TOPIC

Your four practice sets

4 sets · 40 exercises · about 50–70 minutes with writing and review.

10 scored questions, 20 sentence exercises and 10 writing challenges. Time depends on your pace. Start with the quiz or choose the practice you need.

Your scored quiz and self-reviewed exercises are tracked separately on this device.

Questions 1–5 build confidence; 6–10 check transfer and detail. Use Practice for feedback after each answer, or Test yourself to check at the end.

Practise, then understand your answers

10 questions · 10 XP per correct answer · explanations included

Answer every question to see your score.0 / 10 answered
Question 1

Which relative pronoun can be omitted?

  1. The teacher who helped me
  2. The book that I bought
  3. The student who arrived
Answer & explanation

The book that I bought. In that I bought, I is the subject and that is the object.

Question 2

The people ___ live upstairs are friendly.

  1. who
  2. whose
  3. where
Answer & explanation

who. Who is the subject of live and refers to people.

Question 3

Choose a correct defining clause.

  1. The bag I bought is blue.
  2. The bag I bought it is blue.
  3. The bag what I bought is blue.
Answer & explanation

The bag I bought is blue.. Do not repeat the object as it inside the relative clause.

Question 4

The person ___ phone rang apologised.

  1. who
  2. whose
  3. which
Answer & explanation

whose. Whose indicates whose phone it was.

Question 5

In “the bus that stops here”, can that be omitted?

  1. Yes, always
  2. No; it is the subject
  3. Only after a comma
Answer & explanation

No; it is the subject. That is the subject of stops and must remain.

Question 6

Choose the clause that identifies a particular group.

  1. Students which arrive late must sign in.
  2. Students who arrive late must sign in.
  3. Students, who arrive late, must sign in.
Answer & explanation

Students who arrive late must sign in.. Without commas, who arrive late restricts the rule to late students.

Question 7

The bike ___ I bought yesterday is blue.

  1. that
  2. who
  3. where
Answer & explanation

that. That introduces a defining clause referring to a thing.

Question 8

Which relative pronoun can be omitted?

  1. who in “the teacher who helped me”
  2. that in “the bus that stopped”
  3. that in “the book that I borrowed”
Answer & explanation

that in “the book that I borrowed”. An object relative pronoun can be omitted. Subject relative pronouns cannot be omitted in these full clauses.

Question 9

Choose the correct version without an object pronoun.

  1. The film who we watched was funny.
  2. The film we watched was funny.
  3. The film watched we was funny.
Answer & explanation

The film we watched was funny.. We is the subject of watched, so the object relative pronoun can be left out.

Question 10

The person ___ called left no message.

  1. who
  2. whose
  3. where
Answer & explanation

who. Who is needed as the subject of called and refers to the person.

SET 2 OF 4 · 10–15 minutes

Build the pattern

Complete the missing words, then compare the expected form. More than one natural answer may be possible; use the cue and explanation.

1. The woman ____ manages the shop is away. (use who)

Answer & explanation

who

The woman who manages the shop is away. (use who)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

2. The bag ____ I left here is blue. (use that)

Answer & explanation

that

The bag that I left here is blue. (use that)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

3. People ____ book early pay less. (use who)

Answer & explanation

who

People who book early pay less. (use who)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

4. The laptop ____ has the larger screen is mine. (use which)

Answer & explanation

which

The laptop which has the larger screen is mine. (use which)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

5. The neighbour ____ car was damaged called us.

Answer & explanation

whose

The neighbour whose car was damaged called us.

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

6. The room ____ we practise is upstairs.

Answer & explanation

where

The room where we practise is upstairs.

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

7. The bus ____ stops here goes downtown. (use that)

Answer & explanation

that

The bus that stops here goes downtown. (use that)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

8. Anyone ____ needs help can ask. (use who)

Answer & explanation

who

Anyone who needs help can ask. (use who)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

9. The course ____ I chose begins soon. (use which)

Answer & explanation

which

The course which I chose begins soon. (use which)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

10. The player ____ ankle hurts cannot continue.

Answer & explanation

whose

The player whose ankle hurts cannot continue.

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

SET 3 OF 4 · 10–15 minutes

Check the details

Complete the missing words, then compare the expected form. More than one natural answer may be possible; use the cue and explanation.

1. The café ____ we usually meet is closed.

Answer & explanation

where

The café where we usually meet is closed.

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

2. The key ____ opens this door is missing. (use that)

Answer & explanation

that

The key that opens this door is missing. (use that)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

3. Students ____ miss the lesson should read the notes. (use who)

Answer & explanation

who

Students who miss the lesson should read the notes. (use who)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

4. The photo ____ you sent is lovely. (use which)

Answer & explanation

which

The photo which you sent is lovely. (use which)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

5. The woman ____ suitcase was missing found it.

Answer & explanation

whose

The woman whose suitcase was missing found it.

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

6. The restaurant ____ serves noodles is popular. (use that)

Answer & explanation

that

The restaurant that serves noodles is popular. (use that)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

7. The customer ____ complained wants a reply. (use who)

Answer & explanation

who

The customer who complained wants a reply. (use who)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

8. The house ____ faces the park is for sale. (use which)

Answer & explanation

which

The house which faces the park is for sale. (use which)

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

9. The child ____ coat is red is my cousin.

Answer & explanation

whose

The child whose coat is red is my cousin.

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

10. The library ____ I study opens early.

Answer & explanation

where

The library where I study opens early.

A defining clause identifies which person or thing you mean, normally without commas. Follow the requested pronoun where more than one is possible.

SET 4 OF 4 · 20–30 minutes

Use it yourself

Write an original answer for each task. Review the guidance to check your work. These are self-review tasks, not automatic grammar grading.

1. Identify only the students who need extra help.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Use a defining clause without commas to restrict the group.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

2. Describe the particular object you lost.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Use a relative clause that distinguishes it from other objects.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

3. Write a defining clause in which who is the subject.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Keep the subject pronoun in the full relative clause.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

4. Write an object relative clause, then omit its pronoun.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

An object pronoun may be omitted when another word supplies the subject.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

5. Identify a person by something they own.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Use whose plus the possessed noun.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

6. Identify a place by an activity that happens there.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Use where with a full clause.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

7. Explain why the people live here is not a full replacement for the people who live here.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Omitting a subject relative pronoun leaves a different or incomplete structure.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

8. Describe a subset of damaged items.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Use a defining clause without commas to specify only that subset.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

9. Write a sentence containing that for a thing.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Use that inside a defining clause and connect it to a clear noun.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

10. Explain how a defining clause changes who a rule applies to.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Show a broad group and then a restricted group in your examples.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

Printable practice

Print this lesson’s original questions with a separate answer key. Use the worksheet for another round without looking at the explanations.

BEYOND MULTIPLE CHOICE

Can you use it yourself?

Try these two tasks before opening the answers. They practise explanation and writing; they do not change your quiz score.

1. Explain or repair

Can you omit who in The learner who called is waiting? Explain.

Check the reasoning

No. Who is the subject of called. In the full clause, removing it would leave called without its subject.

2. Make the meaning

Write a defining clause with an object pronoun, then omit that pronoun.

Compare a possible answer

The book that I borrowed is useful. The book I borrowed is useful. I is the subject of borrowed; that is its object and can be omitted here.

Other wording may be correct. Compare the meaning and verb pattern, not just the words.

RELATED PRACTICE

Defining vs non-defining clauses

See how commas change what your sentence means.