THE IDEA, SIMPLY

The rule, with an example

An active relative clause can sometimes become an -ing phrase; a passive clause can sometimes become a past-participle phrase. Reduction must preserve the intended meaning and attachment. Not every relative clause can be reduced mechanically.

SEE IT IN CONTEXTStudents who are waiting outside → students waiting outside. Books that were published recently → books published recently.
Skills to work on in this practice
  • Recognise -ing and past-participle patterns
  • Preserve active or passive meaning
  • Check what the shorter clause modifies

Preserve the active or passive meaning

UseExampleWhy it works
ActiveStudents waiting outside can come in.Waiting outside describes students who are waiting outside.
PassiveThe notes written yesterday are on the desk.Written yesterday describes notes that were written yesterday.
Check the meaningThe student who won last year is here.Changing this to winning would lose the completed past meaning.

Common mistake

Check: The notes writing yesterday

Use: The notes written yesterday

The notes receive the action, so the passive past-participle form is needed.

How should I practise this?

Read the example and explain the choice before answering. After the exercise, write a new sentence using the same pattern. Revisit any answer you could not explain, even if you guessed correctly.

MORE PRACTICE · SAME TOPIC

Your four practice sets

4 sets · 40 exercises · about 50–70 minutes with writing and review.

10 scored questions, 20 sentence exercises and 10 writing challenges. Time depends on your pace. Start with the quiz or choose the practice you need.

Your scored quiz and self-reviewed exercises are tracked separately on this device.

Questions 1–5 build confidence; 6–10 check transfer and detail. Use Practice for feedback after each answer, or Test yourself to check at the end.

Practise, then understand your answers

10 questions · 10 XP per correct answer · explanations included

Answer every question to see your score.0 / 10 answered
Question 1

“People who are waiting” can become:

  1. People waited
  2. People waiting
  3. People to waited
Answer & explanation

People waiting. An active ongoing description can use an -ing phrase.

Question 2

“The report that was written yesterday” becomes:

  1. The report writing yesterday
  2. The report wrote yesterday
  3. The report written yesterday
Answer & explanation

The report written yesterday. The report receives the action, so use the passive participle written.

Question 3

“The woman carrying a blue bag” describes:

  1. A woman who is carrying it
  2. A woman carried by it
  3. A bag carrying her
Answer & explanation

A woman who is carrying it. The woman is the agent of carrying.

Question 4

Choose the correct reduced passive phrase.

  1. The forms submitted online
  2. The forms submitting online
  3. The forms submit online
Answer & explanation

The forms submitted online. Forms are submitted; the passive participle is submitted.

Question 5

“Anyone wishing to join should email us” means:

  1. Anyone who wishes to join
  2. Anyone who has been joined
  3. Anyone who was joined
Answer & explanation

Anyone who wishes to join. Wishing gives an active description of anyone.

Question 6

Shorten “the students who are waiting outside”.

  1. the students wait outside
  2. the students waiting outside
  3. the students waited outside
Answer & explanation

the students waiting outside. An active continuous relative clause can reduce to an -ing phrase.

Question 7

Shorten “the report that was written yesterday”.

  1. the report written yesterday
  2. the report writing yesterday
  3. the report wrote yesterday
Answer & explanation

the report written yesterday. A passive relative clause can reduce to a past-participle phrase.

Question 8

Which phrase has passive meaning?

  1. the people storing items
  2. the workers carrying boxes
  3. the items stored upstairs
Answer & explanation

the items stored upstairs. Stored describes items that someone has stored; the other -ing phrases describe active doers.

Question 9

Shorten “anyone who wants to join”.

  1. anyone want to join
  2. anyone wanting to join
  3. anyone wanted to join
Answer & explanation

anyone wanting to join. Wanting preserves the active meaning; wanted would change the structure and meaning.

Question 10

Choose the phrase meaning “the bridge that was built in 1900”.

  1. the bridge built in 1900
  2. the bridge building in 1900
  3. the bridge builds in 1900
Answer & explanation

the bridge built in 1900. Built is the past participle and preserves the passive meaning.

SET 2 OF 4 · 10–15 minutes

Build the pattern

Complete the missing words, then compare the expected form. More than one natural answer may be possible; use the cue and explanation.

1. The people who are sitting outside → the people ____

Answer & explanation

sitting outside

The people who are sitting outside → the people sitting outside

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

2. The letter that was sent yesterday → the letter ____

Answer & explanation

sent yesterday

The letter that was sent yesterday → the letter sent yesterday

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

3. The students who are taking the exam → the students ____

Answer & explanation

taking the exam

The students who are taking the exam → the students taking the exam

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

4. The road that was repaired last month → the road ____

Answer & explanation

repaired last month

The road that was repaired last month → the road repaired last month

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

5. Anyone who wishes to join → anyone ____

Answer & explanation

wishing to join

Anyone who wishes to join → anyone wishing to join

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

6. The bags that were left here → the bags ____

Answer & explanation

left here

The bags that were left here → the bags left here

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

7. The man who is carrying the box → the man ____

Answer & explanation

carrying the box

The man who is carrying the box → the man carrying the box

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

8. The food that was prepared earlier → the food ____

Answer & explanation

prepared earlier

The food that was prepared earlier → the food prepared earlier

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

9. The children who are playing in the garden → the children ____

Answer & explanation

playing in the garden

The children who are playing in the garden → the children playing in the garden

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

10. The documents that are stored online → the documents ____

Answer & explanation

stored online

The documents that are stored online → the documents stored online

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

SET 3 OF 4 · 10–15 minutes

Check the details

Complete the missing words, then compare the expected form. More than one natural answer may be possible; use the cue and explanation.

1. The train that is approaching the station → the train ____

Answer & explanation

approaching the station

The train that is approaching the station → the train approaching the station

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

2. The message that was written in pencil → the message ____

Answer & explanation

written in pencil

The message that was written in pencil → the message written in pencil

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

3. The guests who are staying overnight → the guests ____

Answer & explanation

staying overnight

The guests who are staying overnight → the guests staying overnight

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

4. The money that was collected for charity → the money ____

Answer & explanation

collected for charity

The money that was collected for charity → the money collected for charity

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

5. The woman who is speaking on stage → the woman ____

Answer & explanation

speaking on stage

The woman who is speaking on stage → the woman speaking on stage

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

6. The tables that were reserved for us → the tables ____

Answer & explanation

reserved for us

The tables that were reserved for us → the tables reserved for us

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

7. The workers who are repairing the roof → the workers ____

Answer & explanation

repairing the roof

The workers who are repairing the roof → the workers repairing the roof

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

8. The picture that was painted by Ana → the picture ____

Answer & explanation

painted by Ana

The picture that was painted by Ana → the picture painted by Ana

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

9. The customers who are waiting to pay → the customers ____

Answer & explanation

waiting to pay

The customers who are waiting to pay → the customers waiting to pay

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

10. The items that were damaged in transit → the items ____

Answer & explanation

damaged in transit

The items that were damaged in transit → the items damaged in transit

Active clauses can often reduce to -ing phrases; passive clauses can often reduce to past-participle phrases. Preserve the meaning and time relationship.

SET 4 OF 4 · 20–30 minutes

Use it yourself

Write an original answer for each task. Review the guidance to check your work. These are self-review tasks, not automatic grammar grading.

1. Describe people currently waiting using a full clause and a reduced clause.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Use who are waiting, then waiting.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

2. Describe an item someone repaired using both forms.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Use that was repaired, then repaired.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

3. Contrast the person painting with the picture painted.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

The -ing phrase is active; the past participle is passive.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

4. Shorten a clause about students currently studying in a room.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Use studying while preserving who performs the activity.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

5. Shorten a passive clause about a document sent yesterday.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Keep yesterday with the past-participle phrase.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

6. Expand an -ing phrase into a full relative clause.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Choose a suitable be form and preserve the intended time.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

7. Expand a passive participle phrase into a full clause.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Restore a suitable relative pronoun and passive be form.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

8. Explain why people waited outside does not replace people who are waiting outside.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Waited suggests a different structure; waiting preserves this active continuous meaning.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

9. Describe a place or object using a passive participle phrase.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Make it clear that the noun receives the action.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

10. Compare a full and reduced clause and check what may be lost.

What to check

Your wording can vary.

Do not drop important tense, modal or other meaning merely to shorten the sentence.

Check both the form and the meaning. If you are unsure, compare the lesson explanation before marking this exercise reviewed.

Printable practice

Print this lesson’s original questions with a separate answer key. Use the worksheet for another round without looking at the explanations.

BEYOND MULTIPLE CHOICE

Can you use it yourself?

Try these two tasks before opening the answers. They practise explanation and writing; they do not change your quiz score.

1. Explain or repair

Repair the passive description: The forms signing yesterday are ready.

Check the reasoning

The forms signed yesterday are ready. The forms received the action, so use the past participle signed.

2. Make the meaning

Shorten this description without changing its meaning: People who are waiting outside may enter.

Compare a possible answer

People waiting outside may enter. Waiting preserves the active description of people currently in the queue.

Other wording may be correct. Compare the meaning and verb pattern, not just the words.

RELATED PRACTICE

Defining relative clauses

Identify exactly which person or thing you mean.